Visa could deliver 10-13% returns, while being recession resistant

Executive Summary

Based on Visa's Q4 FY2025 guidance, historical performance trajectory, and structural industry tailwinds, we project a 10-13% revenue CAGR over the next five years (2025-2030). This outlook reflects a blend of near-term event-driven acceleration in 2026 (FIFA World Cup, Super Bowl) delivering low double-digit growth, followed by normalization to high-single to low-double digit expansion as secular digitalization trends, value-added services (VAS), and cross-border commerce sustain momentum.

The investment thesis rests on three pillars: (1) Visa's exceptional capital efficiency with ROIC consistently exceeding 30% and rising incrementally, (2) a 50%+ global market share moat in card payments, and (3) the optionality embedded in rapidly growing businesses like Visa Direct (up 38% YoY) and VAS (20%+ growth). For quality-focused investors seeking compounders, Visa exemplifies a critical principle: high return on capital combined with consistent reinvestment creates disproportionate shareholder value over extended periods.

2026: The Event-Driven Inflection Point

Management's Low Double-Digit Guidance

In their Q4 FY2025 earnings call (October 28, 2025), CFO Chris Suh guided to "low double-digit adjusted net revenue growth" for calendar year 2026—specifically 10-12% on a constant-dollar basis. This represents steady acceleration from FY2025's 11-12% growth, underpinned by:

• Continued pricing benefits: ~200 basis points annually, similar to FY2025

• Resilient consumer spending: Global payments volume up 9% YoY in Q4 FY2025

• Value-added services momentum: VAS revenue growing 20%+ YoY as enterprises adopt fraud detection, analytics, and digital payment solutions

The 2026 U.S. Sports Mega-Cycle

North America enters what industry observers call the "decade of sports," with 2026 serving as the opening act. The FIFA World Cup anchors a packed calendar that includes:

Historical precedent validates these estimates: The 2018 Russia World Cup lifted Visa's international volumes 20%+; the 2022 Qatar edition added ~15% globally. The 2024 Paris Olympics correlated with a 12% YoY cross-border spike. The key difference for 2026: the U.S.-hosted World Cup (first since 1994) amplifies domestic transaction volumes while also capturing inbound travel from 32 competing nations' fan bases.

Visa's exclusive FIFA partnership ensures all venue payments—ticketing, concessions, merchandise—flow through VisaNet. With 104 matches across cities like Los Angeles (projected $594M economic impact), New York/New Jersey, and Miami, the event alone could contribute 1-2 percentage points to full-year revenue growth.

Quarterly Cadence: Q2-Q3 Strength

Management explicitly flagged that Q2 and Q3 2026 will see "stronger growth due to marketing expense related to the Olympics and FIFA." This isn't just about transaction volumes—Visa's sponsorship spend during these events drives brand reinforcement (e.g., "Everywhere You Want to Be" campaigns), which sustains customer acquisition post-event. The 2026 Winter Olympics in Milan-Cortina adds international exposure, though the FIFA World Cup's U.S. footprint dominates.

Beyond 2026: Structural Growth Drivers Through 2030

Baseline Secular Growth: 8-10% Without Events

Strip out the 2026 event tailwind, and Visa's organic growth engine still hums at 8-10% annually, powered by three secular forces:

1. Global Digitalization of Payments

• Cash-to-card migration: Digital wallet users reached 5.5 billion by end of 2025, up from 3.4 billion in 2020 (61% CAGR). Visa processes 260 billion transactions annually across 200+ countries, capturing a growing share of the $50+ trillion global consumer spending pie.

• Emerging markets acceleration: Asia-Pacific and Latin America remain cash-heavy (60-70% of transactions), but smartphone penetration (now 75% globally) is accelerating mobile payment adoption. Visa's deals with local fintechs (e.g., MercadoLibre in LATAM) position it to ride this wave.

2. Cross-Border Commerce Renaissance

• Cross-border volumes: Up 18% YoY on a local currency basis in Q4 FY2025, driven by e-commerce globalization and the return of international travel post-pandemic.

• B2B opportunity: Cross-border B2B payments represent a $125 trillion addressable market, growing 5-7% annually. Visa Business and B2B Connect (blockchain-based) are early but high-margin initiatives.

3. Value-Added Services: The 20%+ Growth Engine VAS—comprising fraud management, risk analytics, digital identity verification, and consulting—now represents a meaningful revenue mix and expands Visa's monetization beyond transaction fees. Key products include:

• CyberSource: Fraud detection for e-commerce merchants

• Visa Direct: Real-time push payments (P2P, gig economy payouts), growing 38% YoY

• Token services: Secures card-not-present transactions; partners with Apple Pay, Google Pay

VAS growth at 20%+ is 3-4x faster than core payment volumes, reflecting Visa's shift from a transaction processor to a data and technology company. By 2030, VAS could contribute 25-30% of revenue (up from ~20% today), pulling the overall CAGR higher.

Capital Efficiency: The ROIC Advantage

Visa's ROIC exceeds 30% and has trended upward over the past decade—a hallmark of what quality investors call a "compounding machine." Using the ROIIC (Return on Incremental Invested Capital) framework from your project knowledge, Visa embodies the principle of employing large amounts of incremental capital at very high rates of return over extended periods.

For every $100 in new capital deployed (e.g., into VAS, network infrastructure, or fintech partnerships), Visa generates $30+ in incremental profit. Contrast this with capital-intensive industries (e.g., airlines, manufacturing) where ROIC struggles to exceed 10%.

Why high ROIC compounds wealth:

• Reinvestment efficiency: At 30% ROIC, Visa needs to reinvest only 33% of profits to achieve 10% organic growth. The remaining 67% flows to shareholders via buybacks ($11B in 2024) and dividends.

• Durability signal: Rising ROIC over time (Visa's has climbed from ~25% in 2015 to 30%+ today) indicates ROIIC exceeds ROIC—meaning each marginal dollar invested creates more value than the last. This is rare and sustainable only with strong competitive moats.

For context, peer Mastercard achieved a 3-year adjusted net revenue CAGR of 19.2% (2022-2024) with similar ROIC dynamics. While Mastercard's growth rate edges higher, Visa's scale ($28.2B FY2024 revenue vs. Mastercard's $25B+) and market share dominance (50%+ globally vs. Mastercard's ~30%) suggest Visa's growth is more sustainable at lower execution risk.

5-Year CAGR Scenarios (2025-2030)

Base Case Rationale (10-11% CAGR)

This aligns with management's historical 10%+ CAGR, Visa's guidance cadence, and analyst consensus (90% "Buy" ratings; avg. price target implies 15% upside). Key logic:

• 2026: Events deliver 11% as guided

• 2027: Normalization to 9% as event tailwinds fade but VAS momentum persists

• 2028-2030: Stabilization at 10% as digitalization + cross-border + VAS offset saturation in developed markets

Bull Case Pathway (12-13% CAGR)

Requires three catalysts:

1. VAS overperformance: Scales faster than expected; contributes 30% of revenue by 2030

2. Emerging market penetration: Asia-Pacific and LATAM adoption accelerates (e.g., India's UPI integrates Visa credentials)

3. M&A optionality: Strategic acquisitions (e.g., buy a B2B fintech) add 1-2% to growth

Bear Case Triggers (8-9% CAGR)

Downside risks include:

• Recession: Consumer spending contraction; cross-border travel slumps

• Fintech disruption: Apple Pay, PayPal, or regional players (Pix in Brazil) erode share

• Regulatory headwinds: Interchange fee caps (e.g., Durbin Amendment expansion in U.S.; EU caps tightening)

Competitive Context: Visa vs. Mastercard

Takeaway: Mastercard's higher recent CAGR reflects aggressive VAS scaling and emerging market gains, but Visa's larger base and network effects (VisaNet processes 260B transactions vs. Mastercard's ~120B) provide stability. For a quality-focused portfolio, Visa offers lower volatility with comparable returns; Mastercard may outperform in bull scenarios but carries higher execution risk.

Investment Implications: Quality at Scale

Why Visa Fits a Quality Compounder Portfolio

A company's valuation multiple is fundamentally a function of both growth and return on capital. Companies with high returns on capital don't need to invest as much to achieve revenue growth, generating more free cash flows and creating more value for shareholders.

Visa checks every box:

• High ROIC (30%+): Capital-light model (no credit risk; purely transaction fees)

• Consistent growth (10%+ CAGR): Secular tailwinds from digitalization

• FCF generation: $13.4B operating cash flow in 2024; 75%+ FCF conversion

• Shareholder returns: $11B buybacks + $2.4B dividends in 2024

Valuation Considerations

At a current P/E of ~30x (assuming $350 stock price, ~$11.50 EPS), Visa trades at a premium to the S&P 500 (22x) but in line with quality peers:

• PEG Ratio: 30x / 11% growth = 2.7 PEG—slightly expensive but justified by ROIC/moat

• EV/EBITDA: ~20x—fair for a business with 60%+ EBITDA margins

Price target implied by base case: If Visa sustains 11% EPS growth (boosted by buybacks) and maintains a 30x multiple, the stock could reach $550-600 by 2030 (+57-71% from $350 today, or 9-11% annualized). This excludes multiple expansion in a bull case.

Risks to Monitor

1. Macro sensitivity: Consumer spending drives 70% of revenue; a 2027-28 recession could shave 2-3% off growth

2. Regulatory uncertainty: Durbin Amendment expansion, EU interchange caps, or antitrust scrutiny

3. Competitive threats: Digital wallets bypassing card networks; CBDCs (central bank digital currencies) disintermediating Visa

4. Currency headwinds: 40%+ of revenue is non-USD; strong dollar crimps reported growth

Conclusion: The Case for Patient Capital

Visa's 5-year CAGR outlook of 10-13% reflects a rare combination of near-term event catalysts, secular digitalization tailwinds, and best-in-class capital efficiency. For investors seeking compounders—businesses that generate excess cash flows and reinvest at high returns—Visa exemplifies the fundamental principle that growth plus ROIC equals value creation.

The 2026 sports bonanza isn't hype; it's a measurable, event-driven accelerant layered atop an 8-10% baseline. Beyond 2026, VAS scaling, cross-border expansion, and emerging market penetration sustain momentum into 2030. At 30%+ ROIC, Visa needs to reinvest only one-third of profits to hit these targets, leaving ample room for shareholder distributions.

Visa fits our "high-quality compounders" criteria: Durable moats, predictable growth, capital discipline. It won't double overnight, but compounding at 10%+ annually while returning billions to shareholders is how generational wealth gets built. High ROIC outperforms over decades when paired with reinvestment optionality. Visa delivers both.

What are your thoughts on the 2026 event tailwinds? Do you see Visa sustaining double-digit growth post-2026, or will normalization pull them below 10%? Reply with your notes and let's refine this thesis together.

Right now it sits on my watchlist, which you can access in real-time in our community.

Would you like to stay ahead of opportunities like this? Join our community where we share real-time trade alerts and deep-dive analyses of businesses with true competitive advantages. Don't just trade the market - invest in excellence.

Want to receive our trade alerts and detailed analysis in real-time? Join our community of value investors who understand that pricing power is the ultimate competitive advantage. Receive our trade alerts on your phone? Download the app here