- 🐝 The Investing Show
- Posts
- SAFRAN
SAFRAN
The Overlooked Giant Ready To Take Off
The Jet Engine Giant Ready for Sustainable Flight
Investment Thesis: Safran commands an unassailable wide-moat business through its dominant position in aerospace propulsion (70% of EBIT), leveraging ultra-high barriers to entry, decades of technical expertise, and sticky long-term customer relationships that generate recurring revenues through maintenance contracts, spare parts, and Rate Per Flight Hour (RPFH) agreements.
Huge Switching Costs with Recurring Revenue
Safran's business model centers on mission-critical propulsion systems where switching costs are prohibitive and customer relationships span decades. Through CFM International (50-50 JV with GE Aerospace), Safran powers 75% of global narrow-body aircraft with its CFM56 and LEAP engines.
Why It's Essential:
Safety-critical systems: Aircraft engines cannot fail—airlines stake their reputation and passenger lives on reliability
Regulatory certification: New engines require 5-7 years and $10+ billion in development and certification
Infrastructure lock-in: Airlines invest heavily in training, tooling, and spare parts inventory specific to each engine type
Stickiness Factor - Extraordinary:
LEAP Rate Per Flight Hour (RPFH) contracts: Airlines pay per flight hour, creating predictable recurring revenue streams over 20+ year aircraft lifespans
Maintenance monopoly: Only Safran can provide genuine spare parts and certified maintenance for CFM engines
Installed base momentum: With nearly 4,000 LEAP engines in service and growing, the aftermarket revenue stream compounds annually
Long-term contracts: Multi-billion dollar engine orders with 10-15 year delivery schedules create revenue visibility
The aftermarket generates 2-3x higher margins than original equipment, with civil aftermarket revenue growing 25% in 2024 driven by post-COVID traffic recovery.
The Gold standard for AI news
AI keeps coming up at work, but you still don't get it?
That's exactly why 1M+ professionals working at Google, Meta, and OpenAI read Superhuman AI daily.
Here's what you get:
Daily AI news that matters for your career - Filtered from 1000s of sources so you know what affects your industry.
Step-by-step tutorials you can use immediately - Real prompts and workflows that solve actual business problems.
New AI tools tested and reviewed - We try everything to deliver tools that drive real results.
All in just 3 minutes a day
Competitive Analysis: David vs. Goliaths, But David Has the Slingshot
Safran faces three primary competitors, but its unique positioning through CFM International provides decisive advantages:
Top 3 Competitors:
1. GE Aerospace (Partner & Competitor)
Market share: 16% standalone (53% including CFM)
Strengths: Widebody engine leadership (GEnx, GE90), military expertise
Weakness: Dependent on CFM partnership for narrow-body dominance
2. Pratt & Whitney (RTX)
Market share: 26% overall
Strengths: Geared Turbofan technology (GTF), A320neo alternative
Critical Weakness: PW1000 durability issues forcing mass groundings and $billions in compensation
3. Rolls-Royce
Market share: 18%
Strengths: Widebody focus (Trent series), premium positioning
Weakness: Limited narrow-body presence, smaller scale
|
What Makes Safran Superior:
1. Narrow-body Market Domination
CFM engines power 72% of active narrow-body fleet globally
Exclusive engine for Boeing 737 MAX (LEAP-1B) and co-dominant on A320neo (LEAP-1A vs. troubled GTF)
Narrow-body market is 80%+ of global aircraft deliveries
2. Reliability Advantage
LEAP engines approaching 50 million flight hours with excellent reliability record
Pratt's GTF reliability issues create competitive opportunity
Advanced machine learning health monitoring provides predictive maintenance edge
3. Scale Economics
1,407 LEAP deliveries in 2024 vs. competitors' smaller volumes
€1+ billion investment in global MRO network expansion
Shared development costs with GE reduce financial risk
4. Technology Leadership
RISE program developing next-generation sustainable engines
15% fuel efficiency improvement over previous generation
First-mover advantage on sustainable aviation fuels (SAF) compatibility
|
ROIC Profile: Strong But Below Our 15% Threshold
Current ROIC Analysis:
2024 ROIC: ~12.7% (GuruFocus data)
WACC: ~9.2%
Economic Profit: Positive 3.5% spread
ROIC Breakdown:
NOPAT Margin: Strong at 15.1% (€4.1B operating income on €27.3B revenue)
Asset Turnover: Moderate due to capital-intensive manufacturing
Historical Range: 6.15% - 12.7% over recent years
Why Below 15%:
Capital Intensity: Massive R&D investments (€646M in H1 2024) for next-gen engines
LEAP Transition Costs: New production facilities and working capital buildup
Geographic Expansion: €1B+ MRO network investments globally
Improving Trajectory:
LEAP RPFH Recognition: Starting 2025, profit recognition begins on LEAP-1A maintenance contracts
Aftermarket Mix Shift: Higher-margin services growing faster than OE sales
Operational Excellence: 150bp margin improvement in 2024 to 15.1%
VERDICT: While currently below our 15% ROIC threshold, Safran shows strong momentum toward achieving this target by 2026-2027 as LEAP aftermarket matures and operational leverage kicks in.
Valuation: Multiple Approaches Point to Fair Value
DCF Analysis:
Base Case Assumptions:
Revenue CAGR: 8-10% (2025-2030) driven by air traffic recovery and LEAP ramp
FCF Growth: €3.0-3.2B (2025) growing to €4.5-5.0B (2030)
Terminal Growth: 2.5% (GDP-plus growth)
WACC: 9.2%
DCF Fair Value: €320-340 per share
|
Sum of Parts:
Propulsion (70% of EBIT): 18x multiple on €3B EBIT = €54B
Equipment & Defense (30% of EBIT): 15x multiple on €1.3B EBIT = €19.5B
Aircraft Interiors: Break-even, minimal value = €0.5B
Total EV: €74B
Net Cash Position: €0.4B
Equity Value: €74.4B / 417M shares = €178 per share
Note: SoP appears conservative vs. DCF due to quality premium deserved by propulsion moat
Exit Multiples:
EV/Sales: 2.4x (vs. industry 2.0-2.8x range)
EV/EBIT: 16.5x (vs. high-quality industrials 15-20x)
P/E: 38x (premium to aerospace peers at 25-35x due to growth quality)
Fair Value Range: €300-340
|
Expected CAGR: Double-Digit Returns Through the Cycle
Base Case CAGR (2025-2030): 12-15%
Revenue Growth Drivers:
Air traffic recovery: Global RPK growth 4-5% annually
Fleet renewal: Airlines upgrading to fuel-efficient LEAP engines
Aftermarket expansion: Installed base growing from 4,000 to 8,000+ LEAP engines
Defense growth: Geopolitical tensions driving military spending
Margin Expansion:
Aftermarket mix shift: From 40% to 50%+ of propulsion revenue
LEAP profitability: Zero-margin RPFH contracts begin recognizing profit 2025+
Operational leverage: Fixed cost absorption on higher volumes
Pricing power: Duopoly market structure enables regular price increases
Capital Allocation:
€5B share buyback program: Commenced 2025, ~2.5% annual yield
€2.90 dividend: +32% increase, 1.0% yield
Growth investments: €1B+ MRO expansion capturing service margin
Risk-Adjusted CAGR: 10-12% accounting for cyclical downturns and execution risks
Current Valuation vs. Price Target
Current Price: €280 (September 2025) Fair Value: €320-340
Upside Potential: 14-21%
Analyst Consensus: €304 average target (range €219-370)
Recommendation: BUY
Trading at reasonable 16.5x EV/EBIT multiple for quality moat business
LEAP aftermarket inflection beginning 2025
Multiple expansion opportunity as ROIC approaches 15%+ threshold
Defensive growth exposure to secular air travel trends
Key Catalysts:
Q4 2025: First LEAP-1A RPFH profit recognition
2026: MRO network expansion completion
2027+: RISE engine program milestones
Ongoing: Share buyback execution and dividend growth
Risks:
Economic downturn reducing air travel demand
Boeing 737 MAX production issues
Competition from sustainable propulsion technologies
Geopolitical restrictions on aerospace trade
I see a wide economic moat that should drive above-market returns as the LEAP aftermarket cycle matures and operational leverage accelerates margin expansion toward our 15%+ ROIC target. Right now it sits on my watchlist, which you can access in real-time in our community.
Would you like to stay ahead of opportunities like this? Join our community where we share real-time trade alerts and deep-dive analyses of businesses with true competitive advantages. Don't just trade the market - invest in excellence.
Want to receive our trade alerts and detailed analysis in real-time? Join our community of value investors who understand that pricing power is the ultimate competitive advantage. Receive our trade alerts on your phone? Download the app here
|