The House Always Wins. And This House Owns 46% of America's Bets

Flutter Entertainment (NYSE: FLUT) | Current Price: $219

Flutter Entertainment stands as the world's largest online betting company by revenue, commanding dominant market positions across the US, UK, Australia, and Italy through a portfolio of premier brands including FanDuel, Paddy Power, Betfair, and PokerStars. With $14.05 billion in 2024 revenue (up 19% YoY) and FanDuel controlling 41-46% of US sports betting gross gaming revenue, the company has successfully navigated the transformation from a European bookmaker to a US-focused digital gaming powerhouse.

What Flutter Actually Does

Flutter operates through four geographic segments: the US segment (41% of revenue via FanDuel), UK & Ireland (26% via Paddy Power, Betfair, and Sky Bet), International (23% via PokerStars and Sisal), and Australia (10% via Sportsbet). The company serves 35 million customers worldwide through 13.9 million average monthly players, processed by a technology workforce of 7,700 employees investing $820 million annually in R&D.

FanDuel emerged as the crown jewel following Flutter's prescient 2018 acquisition just days after the Supreme Court struck down PASPA. Starting from a fantasy sports customer base of 8 million users, FanDuel generated $5.8 billion in 2024 US revenue—more than all competitors combined—and became the only major US sportsbook operator to achieve full-year profitability in 2024.

The international portfolio provides geographic diversification and cash generation to fund US expansion. Betfair operates the world's largest betting exchange (processing 1,000 bets per second, more than all European stock exchanges combined), while PokerStars remains the global leader in online poker.

Why People Keep Betting (Even When They Shouldn't)

Sports betting is unquestionably discretionary consumer spending—a TransUnion study found 54% of US sports bettors earn at least $100,000 annually. During the 2008 recession, US commercial casino revenue declined 4.7%. However, the industry exhibits surprising resilience.

Academic research from Iceland's 2008 economic collapse revealed that gambling participation actually increased during financial difficulty, with lottery participation rising as consumers sought low-cost opportunities for outsized returns. The 90-10 rule (approximately 10% of bettors driving 80% of profitability) means high-value customer retention matters more than broad consumer pullback.

The FanDuel Fortress

Flutter's competitive advantages center on FanDuel's commanding US position and proprietary technology that generates structural margin superiority.

Market share leadership: FanDuel controls 41-46% of US sports betting GGR and has grown to #1 in iGaming with 25-26% share. Combined with DraftKings, the duopoly controls 74-79% of gross gaming revenue. The gap to competitors is enormous: FanDuel's $5.78 billion in 2024 revenue exceeds all other brands combined.

Technology-driven margin advantage: Flutter's proprietary technology platform delivers 14.5% structural gross revenue margins versus DraftKings' 10.5% and the 7% industry average. The company was first to introduce Same Game Parlays (2019), first to bring player props pricing in-house, and achieved a record 16.3% hold rate in June 2024.

Scale economics: FanDuel spends 10% less than competitors while driving 34% more app downloads. The company achieves 1.2x one-year ROI on customer acquisition versus competitors' 3-year payback.

The Moat Is Getting Wider

FanDuel's moat is demonstrably expanding rather than narrowing. iGaming market share grew from 17% to 26% between 2022 and 2024, while hold rates expanded from 7% (2020) to 12%+ (2024). The competitor attrition rate confirms barriers to entry: 12+ brands reduced US footprint or exited in 2024 (Betway, Betfred, Unibet, WynnBet, SI Sportsbook, FOX Bet).

ESPN Bet has achieved under 6% share versus its 20% target. Fanatics represents the most credible emerging threat at 7-10% share.

The Balance Sheet: Solid, Not Spectacular

Flutter carries $6.74 billion in total debt against $3.46 billion in cash, with net debt of $5.16 billion. The 2.2x leverage ratio sits within management's 2.0-2.5x target. Fitch affirmed its BBB- investment grade rating with a stable outlook in April 2025.

The balance sheet has improved meaningfully—leverage fell from 3.1x in December 2023 to 2.2x in December 2024—but the company remains in investment mode with substantial debt from recent acquisitions.

From Losses to Profits: The Earnings Inflection

Flutter's earnings reflect a company that has transitioned from heavy investment to profitability:

• 2022: $(1.22B) net income, ~$(6.94) EPS

• 2023: $43M net income, ~$0.24 EPS

• 2024: $162M net income, ~$0.91 EPS

• 2025E: $8.78-$8.90 EPS (analyst consensus)

• 2026E: $10.87 EPS

That's a projected 46.6% EPS CAGR through 2026. The forward ROE forecast reaches 27% within three years.

Margins Are Inflecting Positive

Net margins have turned the corner: from (10.4%) in 2022 to +1.2% in 2024. The adjusted EBITDA margin stands at approximately 16.5% with management targeting 25% by 2027—representing 700 basis points of expansion. Gross margins of 46% provide substantial runway for operating leverage.

ROIC: The One Ugly Number

Current ROIC of approximately 2.5% significantly trails the estimated 8.79% WACC, indicating incremental capital deployment is currently value-dilutive. This reflects Flutter's strategic decision to prioritize market share capture during the US market's land-grab phase.

The trajectory is improving as FanDuel achieves profitability at scale, but ROIC won't cross cost of capital until the investment phase winds down.

Reinvesting Aggressively for Growth

Flutter remains in expansion mode: €2.3B for Snaitech (Italy), $1.755B for full FanDuel ownership, $500M annual capex, and $200-300M investment in FanDuel Predicts for 2026. The UK & Irish and Australian operations remain highly cash-generative, funding US growth investments.

Capital Returns: Buybacks Over Dividends

Flutter suspended dividends to prioritize growth but announced a $5 billion multi-year share buyback program in September 2024, targeting ~$1 billion for return in 2025. All repurchased shares are cancelled, reducing share count.

Valuation: Priced for Growth, But Not Excessively

The PEG ratio of 0.71 suggests attractive valuation relative to growth. Of 21 analysts, 19 rate the stock Buy or Strong Buy with zero sell ratings.

Quality Scorecard

Overall Score: 63/100

Flutter Entertainment presents a compelling case built on dominant market position, structural margin advantages, and improving profitability trajectory. FanDuel's 41-46% market share and technology-driven 14.5% hold rate are advantages that have proven durable as competitors have failed or retreated.

Key risks include regulatory headwinds (UK taxes rising to 40% for iGaming), competitive pressure from DraftKings and emerging Fanatics, and currently low ROIC during the investment phase. Texas and California remain closed indefinitely.

At a forward P/E of 25x with a PEG ratio of 0.71 and analyst consensus implying 47% upside, the stock prices in substantial uncertainty that may prove overstated. For investors with conviction in legal US sports betting and iGaming, Flutter represents the highest-quality exposure to this market—even if the ROIC says you're paying for the privilege of being patient. Right now it sits on my watchlist, which you can access in real-time in our community.

Would you like to stay ahead of opportunities like this? Join our community where we share real-time trade alerts and deep-dive analyses of businesses with true competitive advantages. Don't just trade the market - invest in excellence.

Want to receive our trade alerts and detailed analysis in real-time? Join our community of value investors who understand that pricing power is the ultimate competitive advantage. Receive our trade alerts on your phone? Download the app here